REVIEW: ETRUS GRAVE – Tophet

 

ETRUS GRAVE – Tophet

My Graveyard Productions

Originally reviewed in 2010

The second full‑length release from Etrus Grave arrives with a strong pedigree, given that the band was founded by Fulberto Serena, a key figure in the legendary Dark Quarterer. Musically, Tophet moves within mid‑tempo power metal, enriched by occasional epic overtones that clearly reflect Serena’s roots.

Despite the solid musicianship and the band’s unmistakable identity, the songwriting doesn’t consistently rise to the level one might expect from such lineage. For me, “Hastings” emerges as the album’s most compelling moment, offering a clearer sense of direction and emotional weight. In contrast, the re‑recorded version of Dark Quarterer’s “Colossus of Argil” feels noticeably weaker than the original, lacking the depth and intensity that made the first rendition memorable.

Tophet is not a bad album—far from it. It simply doesn’t deliver enough standout material to justify prioritizing it over stronger releases in the genre. Listeners curious about Serena’s post–Dark Quarterer work may still find value here, but those seeking a truly essential addition to their collection will likely discover more rewarding options elsewhere.

Ioannis    Kaskamanidis